Adept Press

General Category => My Stuff => Topic started by: James_Nostack on February 16, 2015, 04:25:47 PM

Title: [Circles] "Commitment" uses full or current Quickness?
Post by: James_Nostack on February 16, 2015, 04:25:47 PM
In Circle of Hands, prior to rolling dice a character decides how aggressive or defensive she wishes to be; this is called the "commitment" in the rules, and generally works by taking twice your Quickness, and allocating those points between Attack and Defense.

Here's the question: the text seems a little unclear about whether that's a character's full, healthy Quickness, or the character's current, "I just took a hell of a lot of damage" Quickness. 

For the full healthy Quickness point of view: the example of combat on pages 99 and 100 of the text has Krimhilde down to Quickness 1 (or Quickness 3 under one alternate scenario), but then has 12 points to commit to full attack.

For the current, I'm-badly-injured Quickness, see the sample character sheet.

Note that if you're not wearing armor, and take a pretty serious hit, that's going to deplete your Quickness pretty quickly, making it almost impossible to defend yourself, which creates a death spiral.  I can see this as part of the "harshness" of the setting, especially since if your Quickness gets clobbered you won't be able to make a Q v 12 roll to escape.  But it also seems like if a lone Circle Knight gets jumped without armor, and the other side has advantage, that's pretty much all she wrote. 
Title: Re: [Circles] "Commitment" uses full or current Quickness?
Post by: James_Nostack on February 16, 2015, 04:27:34 PM
Ooops just read page 99 again and realized my mistake: Krimhilde is in fact fully armored and thus her Quickness is unimparied.  So maybe it really is current Quickness all along.
Title: Re: [Circles] "Commitment" uses full or current Quickness?
Post by: Ron Edwards on February 16, 2015, 04:39:39 PM
Current Quickness. Yeah, if you're damaged down to Quickness 2, you have 2/0, 1/1, or 0/2, good luck.

You about gave me a heart attack with that text reference.