[IaWA] Advantage dice question

<< < (2/2)

lumpley:
You, me, Mitch. You punch me in the face, win. Ow! Mitch punches you in the face, wins. I don't get a go.

In round 2, you roll an advantage die for punching me in the face and winning. Mitch rolls an advantage die for punching you in the face and winning. I do not roll an advantage die.

-Vincent

Ry:
Damn.  I've been playing wrong, and now my players' strategizing will be different. 
So any win during round 1 grants advantage in round 2.  Any win in round 2 grants advantage in round 3.

Valvorik:
eeep, 4 here have been playing wrong too!

Rob

lumpley:
Quote from: Ryan Stoughton on March 19, 2008, 01:40:55 PM

So any win during round 1 grants advantage in round 2.  Any win in round 2 grants advantage in round 3.

Exactly.

If you've been playing it wrong, it's affected your fine-grained strategizing, but I can't imagine it's had any effect on your play overall.

The game has some significant rules, where if you play THEM wrong, you're playing the game wrong. The small-scale details of just precisely how advantage dice work? More or less arbitrary. I went with what seemed self-evident to me, and I stand behind them as perfectly good. Other ways, ways that might seem more self-evident to you, might be perfectly good too. I have no reason to think otherwise.

Whether you want to change the way you're playing from one perfectly good way to the perfectly good way that I thought of, is your call.

-Vincent

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[*] Previous page