[DitV] A wife by any other name, + two rules questions

[lumpley]

Close enough! I don't play with your #2. When I play, acknowledging the gunshot at all -- seeing the raise in any way -- counts as escalating to gunfighting. But the way you're doing it won't break the game, so that's fine.

-Vincent

[Welkerfan]

It seems like number 1) makes the choice to escalate more meaningful.  The opponent(s) always get the dice, too, so there's always both narrative and mechanical risk to escalation.

[Jim D.]

Yeah, that does make much, much more sense.  I like your take on it, Moreno -- puts things into perspective.